关于生成式音乐产品 Suno，Hacker News 有个帖子下面有这么一段评论：
Being a musical artist isn't about knowing how to use tools to make a sound, it's about having the taste to know which sounds out of many are the right ones to express what you're trying to say. It's about having an idea you want to create to put out into the world.
People without ideas and taste will play with this stuff for a while because it feels like it gives them a shortcut to talent, but after a while the novelty will wear off and they'll once again have to confront the fact that they have neither ideas, taste, nor talent.
If you're just in need of lowest-common-denominator sound-alike shit, go nuts. If you're interested in music, I suggest also spending time learning to actually be a creative artist, using whatever tools you want.
成为一个音乐艺术家并不仅仅是知道如何使用工具来制造声音，而是要有品味，知道在众多声音中选择哪些是正确的，以表达你想要传达的信息。它是关于有一个想法，想要创造并展示给世界看。
那些没有想法和品味的人会玩弄这些东西一段时间，因为它给他们一种快速获得才华的捷径，但过一段时间，新奇感会消退，他们将再次面对一个事实：他们既没有想法，也没有品味，更没有才华。
如果你只是需要最普通的模仿垃圾音乐，请尽情发挥。如果你对音乐感兴趣，我建议你也花时间学习如何成为一个真正有创造力的艺术家，无论使用什么工具。
我基本认同他的观点，且适用现在大多数生成式 AI 工具。不过，我也在玩，只是因为觉得好玩，没玩过，而且很强大，至于能做成什么，完全看自己品味了。
Being a musical artist isn't about knowing how to use tools to make a sound, it's about having the taste to know which sounds out of many are the right ones to express what you're trying to say. It's about having an idea you want to create to put out into the world.
People without ideas and taste will play with this stuff for a while because it feels like it gives them a shortcut to talent, but after a while the novelty will wear off and they'll once again have to confront the fact that they have neither ideas, taste, nor talent.
If you're just in need of lowest-common-denominator sound-alike shit, go nuts. If you're interested in music, I suggest also spending time learning to actually be a creative artist, using whatever tools you want.
成为一个音乐艺术家并不仅仅是知道如何使用工具来制造声音，而是要有品味，知道在众多声音中选择哪些是正确的，以表达你想要传达的信息。它是关于有一个想法，想要创造并展示给世界看。
那些没有想法和品味的人会玩弄这些东西一段时间，因为它给他们一种快速获得才华的捷径，但过一段时间，新奇感会消退，他们将再次面对一个事实：他们既没有想法，也没有品味，更没有才华。
如果你只是需要最普通的模仿垃圾音乐，请尽情发挥。如果你对音乐感兴趣，我建议你也花时间学习如何成为一个真正有创造力的艺术家，无论使用什么工具。
我基本认同他的观点，且适用现在大多数生成式 AI 工具。不过，我也在玩，只是因为觉得好玩，没玩过，而且很强大，至于能做成什么，完全看自己品味了。